Cigar Butt Investing
Cigar butt investing describes buying a deeply discounted business for a remaining opportunity to extract value, even when the business has weak long-term prospects. The metaphor refers to a discarded cigar with one usable puff left.
Buffett’s example: Berkshire’s textile business
In the 1989 shareholder letter, Buffett looks back on buying control of Berkshire because its textile business appeared cheap. A temporary improvement might allow a profitable sale, but a poor business can keep generating new problems. Weak ongoing returns can consume the benefit of a low purchase price.
He also discusses the department store Hochschild Kohn: the purchase looked attractive against book value, yet he was fortunate to sell it roughly at cost. These examples explain his increasing preference, influenced by Charlie Munger, for businesses with stronger economics.
Cheap shares and good businesses
A discount and a durable competitive advantage answer different questions. A discount concerns the relationship between price and estimated value. Business quality concerns the ability to earn and reinvest over time. A bargain can disappoint if its value declines while the investor waits.
For a reading exercise, compare two hypothetical situations: an asset expected to be sold soon, and a business expected to operate for decades. In the first, the realizable asset value and timing dominate the analysis. In the second, recurring earnings, capital needs and competition matter much more. Neither a low share price nor a low price-to-book ratio resolves those questions on its own.
Was Dexter Shoe a cigar butt investment?
Dexter is better understood as a mistaken assessment of competitive strength. In the 2007 shareholder letter, Buffett explains that the durable advantage he believed Dexter possessed disappeared. Paying with Berkshire shares made the eventual cost much larger. It should not be casually classified as another liquidation-style bargain.
Read next
- 1989 shareholder letter — the cigar butt discussion.
- Wonderful company at a fair price — the alternative emphasis.
- Economic moat and margin of safety — business durability and valuation risk.